When I got mine replaced they look exactly the same just different material. The other was some sort of cast. My new ones are holding up well in the cold weather but I try not to slam the door any more
Just a heads up Yamaha is being super ridiculous, this warranty has an expiration date. I just called to replace mine, they broke about 1 year after I bought mine and I just didn't care enough. Saw this post and called in, claim denied under expired offer. Never received an email or letter in the mail about the offer.